Wearables report numbers about your body. Almost nobody publishes how accurate those numbers are.
We do. Below is the bar for ten measurements, and every major maker graded against it — on published validation studies only.
Independent, based on published validation literature as of Oct 14, 2026. Not affiliated with the makers listed.
How this board works. For each measurement we publish THE BAR — the accuracy line, taken from the validation literature or a standards body, with its source. A maker MEETS the bar when at least one published validation of a device it sells reaches the bar under the conditions named. A maker FALLS SHORT when published validations exist and none reaches the bar. NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND means we searched PubMed, Europe PMC, and the maker’s own documentation on Oct 14, 2026 and found no published validation — that is an absence of evidence, not a failure, and it is never graded as one. Where published results conflict, both are printed. A maker that does not report a measurement is marked, not graded.
The re-grade rule. Any maker can be re-graded the day it publishes validation that meets a bar. Corrections and new evidence are invited at gus@zohrxllc.com — send the study, and the board changes.
ZOH is held to the same board. ZOH sells no sensor of its own; what ZOH displays carries its source and its method — HRV shown as SDNN or RMSSD, never blended; body-fat percentage shown as an estimate — and every product ZOH sells carries a filed evidence grade: https://zohhealth.com/#/evidence. We don’t believe it. We measure it.
Basis: the standardized wearable-sleep evaluation framework of Menghini et al. (2021) works an example minimal detectable change of ≈39 minutes for a single night — a device whose typical error exceeds 30 minutes cannot resolve the smallest sleep change a person would act on. Context: a 2025 meta-analysis of 24 studies and 798 participants found pooled device–PSG total-sleep-time differences of ~17 minutes (PMID 39484805).
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | MEETS | Apple Watch Series 8: MAE 27.75 min, bias +19.60 (Schyvens et al. 2025, SLEEP Advances, PMID 40303381). Note: Series 6 read through a third-party app showed absolute bias 48.1 min (Miller et al. 2022, PMID 36016077). |
| Oura | MEETS | Ring Gen2: absolute bias 29.0 min (Miller et al. 2022, PMID 36016077). |
| Fitbit | FALLS SHORT | Charge 5 MAE 31.24 min; Sense MAE 35.23 min (Schyvens et al. 2025, PMID 40303381). |
| Garmin | FALLS SHORT | Vivosmart 4 MAE 54.36 min (Schyvens 2025); Forerunner 245 absolute bias 45.3 min (Miller 2022). |
| Whoop | FALLS SHORT | 4.0 MAE 50.31 min (Schyvens 2025); 3.0 absolute bias 30.3 min (Miller 2022). |
| Withings | FALLS SHORT | ScanWatch MAE 60.94 min (Schyvens 2025). |
| Polar | FALLS SHORT | Vantage V absolute bias 31.2 min (Miller 2022). |
| Samsung | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Galaxy Watch sleep studies located report desaturation/apnea indices, not total-sleep-time error vs PSG. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Basis: kappa 0.60 is the “substantial agreement” threshold of Landis & Koch (1977, Biometrics, PMID 843571).
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | FALLS SHORT | Multi-state kappa 0.20 (Miller et al. 2022, PMID 36016077); six-device range 0.21–0.53 (Schyvens et al. 2025, PMID 40303381). |
| Fitbit | FALLS SHORT | Sense 2 stage sensitivities 61.7–78.0% (Robbins et al. 2024, Sensors, PMID 39460013); kappa within the 0.21–0.53 six-device range (Schyvens 2025). |
| Garmin | FALLS SHORT | Multi-state kappa 0.25 (Miller 2022). |
| Oura | FALLS SHORT | Multi-state kappa 0.43 (Miller 2022); per-stage accuracy 75.5% (light) to 90.6% (REM) (Svensson et al. 2024, Sleep Medicine, PMID 38382312). |
| Whoop | FALLS SHORT | Four-stage kappa 0.47 (Miller et al. 2020, J Sports Sci, PMID 32713257); 0.44 (Miller 2022). |
| Polar | FALLS SHORT | Multi-state kappa 0.28 (Miller 2022). |
| Withings | FALLS SHORT | ScanWatch was one of the six devices in Schyvens 2025; no device in that study exceeded kappa 0.53. |
| Samsung | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Basis: Shcherbina et al. (2017, J Pers Med, PMID 28538708) — 7 devices, 60 participants, telemetry reference. Six of seven devices met 5% cycling; three met it walking.
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | MEETS | Walking median error 2.5%; lowest overall heart-rate error of the 7 devices (Shcherbina 2017). |
| Fitbit | MEETS | Sense rest/recovery MAPE ≤ 3% vs ECG (Jamieson et al. 2024, Sci Rep, PMID 39362983). Also published: peak-exercise MAPE ~12% (Jamieson 2024); Surge walking median error in the 6.5–8.8% band (Shcherbina 2017). |
| Garmin | MEETS | Vivoactive 4 rest/recovery MAPE ≤ 3% vs ECG (Jamieson 2024). Peak-exercise MAPE ~7% (same study). |
| Whoop | MEETS | Nocturnal heart-rate absolute bias 0.7 bpm, ICC 0.99 vs ECG (Miller 2022, PMID 36016077). Agreement is lower during dynamic resistance exercise (Støve & Hansen 2023, PMID 36803578). |
| Polar | MEETS | H10 RR-interval detection 99.6% correct vs visual ECG inspection; 99.4% at high exercise intensity (Gilgen-Ammann et al. 2019, PMID 31004219). |
| Samsung | FALLS SHORT | Gear S2: highest overall heart-rate error of the 7 devices; cycling median error 5.1%, walking in the 6.5–8.8% band (Shcherbina 2017). No published validation at or under 5% located. |
| Amazfit (Xiaomi) | FALLS SHORT | Mi Band 3 resting MAE 10.2 bpm — the highest of the consumer devices tested (Bent et al. 2020, npj Digit Med, PMID 32047863). |
| Oura | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | No published heart-rate error statistics vs ECG for daytime/exercise conditions located. Nocturnal heart rate is scored on the resting board below. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Withings | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | No published heart-rate error statistics vs ECG located. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | MEETS | Absolute bias 1.5 bpm, ICC 0.96 (Miller et al. 2022, PMID 36016077). |
| Fitbit | MEETS | Charge 4 nocturnal MAE 1.16 ± 0.42 bpm vs PSG-ECG (Doheny et al. 2024, J Clin Sleep Med, PMID 38450553; cohort n=10, Huntington’s disease). |
| Oura | MEETS | Nightly heart-rate bias −0.63 bpm, r² = 0.996 (Kinnunen et al. 2020, Physiol Meas, PMID 32217820). |
| Whoop | MEETS | Absolute bias 0.7 bpm, ICC 0.99 (Miller 2022). |
| Polar | MEETS | Vantage V absolute bias 1.5 bpm, ICC 0.93 (Miller 2022). |
| Garmin | FALLS SHORT | Forerunner 245 absolute bias 5.4 bpm, ICC 0.41 (Miller 2022). |
| Samsung | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | No resting-heart-rate-specific published error figure located. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Withings | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Which statistic a maker reports — SDNN or RMSSD — is scored in the transparency set below. The two statistics are not interchangeable.
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Oura | MEETS | Nightly HRV r² = 0.980, bias −1.2 ms vs ECG (Kinnunen et al. 2020, PMID 32217820). Note: a 5-minute-window comparison found ICC 0.63 (Miller et al. 2022, PMID 36016077). |
| Whoop | MEETS | RMSSD ICC 0.99 vs ECG; limits of agreement ±7.6 ms (Miller 2022). The paper discloses that the raw data were provided by the manufacturer. |
| Polar | MEETS | H10 RR intervals — the intervals Polar HRV is computed from — 99.6% correct vs ECG (Gilgen-Ammann et al. 2019, PMID 31004219). Note: Vantage V optical nightly HRV ICC 0.65 (Miller 2022). |
| Apple | FALLS SHORT | Apple Watch HRV vs ECG ICC 0.67, limits of agreement ±55.2 ms (Miller 2022). Apple reports SDNN, not RMSSD — see the transparency set. |
| Garmin | FALLS SHORT | HRV ICC 0.24, limits of agreement ±92.0 ms (Miller 2022). |
| Fitbit | FALLS SHORT | Charge 4 HRV ICC 0.69 (healthy) / 0.87 (COPD) vs Polar H10 (Hermans et al. 2024, JMIR mHealth, PMID 39504450). |
| Samsung | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Withings | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Basis: the FDA premarket accuracy criterion for reflectance pulse oximeters, as applied in Walzel et al. (2023, PMID 38005550). ISO 80601-2-61 permits Arms ≤ 4.0%.
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | MEETS | Watch Series 8 Arms 2.2%, bias −0.1 vs reference oximeter, full range (Walzel et al. 2023, Sensors); Series 7 MAE 2.2% vs clinical oximeter (Jiang et al. 2023, PLOS Digital Health, PMID 37437005). Caveat: under controlled hypoxemia (SaO2 < 88%), Series 7 Arms was 5.82% (Jiang et al. 2026, JMIR Form Res, PMID 41894520). |
| Samsung | MEETS | Galaxy Watch 4 RMSD 1.8% vs arterial SaO2 under an FDA/ISO-style protocol (Browne et al. 2025, Sensors, PMID 40096012). Note: Galaxy Watch 5 Arms 3.8% vs reference oximeter (Walzel 2023). |
| Withings | MEETS | ScanWatch RMSE 2.97% / 3.00% (right/left wrist) vs co-oximetry (Kirszenblat & Edouard 2021, JMIR, PMID 33857011 — the paper’s authors include Withings employees); Arms 3.5% vs reference oximeter (Walzel 2023). Note: measurement success rate 69.5% in one clinical cohort (Jiang 2023). |
| Garmin | FALLS SHORT | Fenix 5X Plus at 4,559 m: bias +7.0% vs arterial blood gas, limits of agreement −6.5 to +20.5; the authors state the device did not meet acceptable validity criteria (Schiefer et al. 2021, Sensors, PMID 34640680). |
| Fitbit | FALLS SHORT | Charge 4 SpO2 agreement poor in a COPD cohort (ICC 0.32), with overestimation (Hermans et al. 2024, PMID 39504450). Scored on agreement; no Arms-protocol study located. |
| Polar | FALLS SHORT | Elixir sensor as shipped: RMSE 4.13% vs arterial SaO2 under an ISO-style protocol (Russell et al. 2024, Med Sci Sports Exerc, PMID 38635406). A post-hoc recalibration in the same paper reached 2.67%; this board grades the shipped algorithm. |
| Oura | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Whoop | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Basis: the CADENCE-Adults validity catalog (Mora-Gonzalez et al. 2022, PMID 36076265) and the 158-publication systematic review of Fuller et al. (2020, PMID 32897239). Slow-speed and free-living results degrade for most devices; free-living findings are printed where published.
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | MEETS | Watch Series 1 MAPE 4% at normal speeds (CADENCE catalog). |
| Fitbit | MEETS | Ionic MAPE 4% (CADENCE catalog); Sense MAPE 6.8–8.0% vs hand tally (Jamieson et al. 2024, PMID 39362983). Free-living caveat: Charge 2 overcounted by +12.4% (mean percentage error) in older adults (Tedesco et al. 2019, PMID 31219048). |
| Garmin | MEETS | vivoactive 3 MAPE 1–2% (CADENCE catalog); Vivoactive 4 MAPE 0.9–1.8% vs hand tally (Jamieson 2024). |
| Samsung | MEETS | Gear Fit2 MAPE 1–2% at normal speeds (CADENCE catalog). |
| Polar | MEETS | M600 MAPE 6% at normal speeds (CADENCE catalog). |
| Whoop | DOES NOT REPORT | Whoop does not publish a step count. Not scored. |
| Withings | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | For current devices. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Oura | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Basis: the ±3.5% standard-error-of-estimate criterion for %fat prediction (Lohman, 1992, as carried in ACSM body-composition guidance). A correlation coefficient alone is not agreement and does not meet this bar.
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Samsung | FALLS SHORT | Galaxy Watch 5 BIA vs DXA (n=108): bias −0.88 pp, MAE 2.87 pp, limits of agreement −7.85 to +6.10 pp — and the study’s equivalence test was not met (Carrier et al. 2025, Front Sports Act Living, PMID 41341278). |
| Withings | FALLS SHORT | Body Cardio vs DEXA: fat-mass median absolute error −3.7 kg (IQR −8.0 to +0.28) (Frija-Masson et al. 2021, JMIR mHealth, PMID 33929337). Withings’ own Body Scan study reports r = 0.99 vs DEXA — a correlation, published without bias or limits of agreement, so it does not meet this bar. |
| Garmin | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Index S2: no peer-reviewed DEXA validation located (reviews and forums only). Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Fitbit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Aria line: no peer-reviewed DEXA validation located. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit (Xiaomi) | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Mi Body Composition scales: no DEXA validation located on PubMed. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Apple | DOES NOT SELL | No body-composition device in the current line. Not scored. |
| Oura | DOES NOT SELL | No body-composition device in the current line. Not scored. |
| Whoop | DOES NOT SELL | No body-composition device in the current line. Not scored. |
| Polar | DOES NOT SELL | No body-composition device in the current line. Not scored. |
| COROS | DOES NOT SELL | No body-composition device in the current line. Not scored. |
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Whoop | MEETS | Within ~1 breath/min of polysomnography on average (Berryhill et al. 2020, J Clin Sleep Med, PMID 32043961); bias 1.8%, precision error 6.7% as tabulated in the npj Digital Medicine 2021 wearable respiratory-rate review. |
| Fitbit | FALLS SHORT | Charge 4 respiratory-rate ICC 0.84 (COPD) / 0.77 (healthy) vs a Polar H10-derived reference (Hermans et al. 2024, PMID 39504450). |
| Apple | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Garmin | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Samsung | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Oura | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Withings | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Polar | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Every maker that reports temperature reports deviation from the wearer’s own baseline, not an absolute clinical temperature. The board grades the validation, and prints that fact.
| Maker | Grade | Published evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Oura | MEETS | Meets for relative tracking: nocturnal finger skin temperature tracked menstrual-cycle phase change comparably to oral temperature — follicular-to-luteal difference 0.30 °C (skin) vs 0.23 °C (oral); daily correlation with oral temperature r = 0.56 (Maijala et al. 2019, BMC Women’s Health, PMID 31783840). |
| Apple | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Reports wrist-temperature deviation; no published validation vs reference thermometry located. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Fitbit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Garmin | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Samsung | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Whoop | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Reports skin-temperature deviation. Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Withings | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Polar | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| COROS | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
| Amazfit | NO PUBLIC VALIDATION FOUND | Searched Oct 14, 2026. |
Not accuracy — conduct. Facts from vendor documentation, checked Oct 14, 2026.
| Maker | Publishes its HRV statistic? | Raw data export? | Third-party API / sharing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple | Yes — SDNN (Apple Support). An RMSSD “Recovery HRV” was added for Series 12 / Ultra 4 in 2026. | Yes — Health app export | No cloud API — HealthKit is on-device only, read with the member’s permission |
| Fitbit (Google) | Yes — RMSSD (Fitbit help) | Yes — account export | Free API (Fitbit Web API / Google Health API). The legacy Fitbit Web API path ends Oct 30, 2026. |
| Garmin | Yes — RMSSD (Garmin support, HRV Status) | Yes — account export | Application-gated — Garmin Health API partner application |
| Samsung | Not named in consumer documentation | Yes — Samsung Health data download | Application-gated — Health Data SDK partner approval |
| Oura | Yes — RMSSD (Oura support) | Yes — Oura on the Web export | Free API — Oura API v2 (a member’s Oura membership governs whether data exists) |
| Whoop | Yes — RMSSD (Whoop support) | Yes — app export | Free API — Whoop developer API |
| Withings | Not published — no HRV method documentation located | Yes — account export | API exists; accounts created after Oct 12, 2026 require a Withings+ subscription to share data with third-party apps |
| Polar | Yes — RMSSD (Polar support, Nightly Recharge) | Yes — Polar Flow export | Free API — Polar AccessLink |
| COROS | Not named in consumer documentation | Yes — Training Hub export | Application-gated — API access by application |
| Amazfit (Zepp) | Yes — RMSSD (HRV4Training reference compilation, Oct 2026) | Yes — app export | Application-gated — partner API |
| Hume | — | Via Apple Health / Health Connect sync | No API. (Hume is listed for transparency only; no published validation literature was located for its devices, so it is not on the accuracy boards.) |
What would change these grades? Published validation. A maker that funds an independent study, posts the protocol, and reports the error against a reference standard moves the day the paper is public — in either direction. Until then, the grades above are what the published record supports, no more and no less.
Board dated Oct 14, 2026. It will be re-run as new validation publishes. Corrections: gus@zohrxllc.com.